GayCities Gay Travel Guides
GayCities Gay Travel Guides
  • Cities
  • Articles
  • Best of 2022
  • Add a review
  • Sign In
  • Home

  • Cities
  • Articles
  • Add a review

  • Best of 2022

  • Sign In
  • Register

North America / United States / New York

New York Restaurants

  • Gay New York
  • Bars & Clubs
  • Restaurants
  • Bathhouses
  • Hotels
  • Shops
  • Arts
  • Gyms
  • Beaches
  • More
  • History
  • Map

New York Restaurants 2023: Pizza

  • List View
  • Map View
  • Filter
Most Loved
  • Most loved
  • Alphabetically
  • Neighborhood
  • Photo of John's Pizzeria Times Square
    Love it or not?

    John's Pizzeria Times Square

    Holy Pizza

    Times Square, 260 West 44th Street 100% Love it
    Explore
  • Photo of John's of Bleecker St.
    Love it or not?

    John's of Bleecker St.

    The original brick oven pizza

    West Village, 278 Bleecker St 100% Love it
    Explore
  • Photo of Lenny's Pizzeria
    Love it or not?

    Lenny's Pizzeria

    Saturday Night post-Fever

    Brooklyn, 594 5th Ave Brooklyn 80% Love it
    Explore
  • Photo of Nizza
    Love it or not?

    Nizza

    "Be Italian"

    Hell's Kitchen, 630 Ninth Avenue 100% Love it
    Explore
  • Photo of Lombardi's
    Love it or not?

    Lombardi's

    Classic NY Pizza

    Soho, 32 Spring Street 100% Love it
    Explore
  • Photo of Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria
    Love it or not?

    Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria

    Coal oven by Carnegie Hall

    Times Square, 117 West 57th Street 100% Love it
    Explore
  • Photo of Grimaldi's Pizzeria
    Love it or not?

    Grimaldi's Pizzeria

    Coal-fired Brooklyn

    Brooklyn, 19 Cadman Plz W Brooklyn 100% Love it
    Explore
  • Photo of Keste Pizza & Vino
    Love it or not?

    Keste Pizza & Vino

    Traditional Neapolitan

    West Village, 271 Bleecker St 100% Love it
    Explore
  • Photo of Rocco's Pizza Joint
    Love it or not?

    Rocco's Pizza Joint

    Favorite slice?

    Chelsea, 162 7th Ave 100% Love it
    Explore
  • Photo of Angelo's Pizza
    Love it or not?

    Angelo's Pizza

    A slice of heaven on the UES

    Upper East Side, 1043 2nd Ave % Love it
    Explore

Related Articles

5 Dry January hangouts that welcome sober socializing

5 Dry January hangouts that welcome sober socializing

5 NYC coffee shops worthy of remote working & cruising

5 NYC coffee shops worthy of remote working & cruising

Did somebody say bottomless mimosas? Top 10 drag brunches in the US

Did somebody say bottomless mimosas? Top 10 drag brunches in the US

See all New York articles

Filter by:

Tags

  • Food (133)
  • Mixed Gay/Straight (126)
  • Mixed Gay/Lesbian (93)
  • $$ - Standard (63)
  • American (62)
  • $$$ - Moderate (62)
  • Italian (38)
  • $ - Budget (32)
  • Coffee House (27)
  • Sunday Brunch (25)
  • Café/Bistro (24)
  • Fusion (23)
  • Cafe / Bistro (22)
  • European (19)
  • Asian (17)
  • Latin / Spanish (16)
  • Comfort Food (15)
  • Mexican (14)
  • Patisserie (14)
  • Seafood (13)
  • Mediterranean (12)
  • Women-led (11)
  • Sushi / Japanese (11)
  • $$$$ - Expensive (10)
  • French (10)
  • Pizza (10)
  • Nice ambiance (9)
  • Outdoor Patio (9)
  • Vegetarian (9)
  • Japanese (8)
  • Sandwich (8)
  • Tapas / Small Plates (8)
  • LGBTQ-owned (8)
  • Trans-friendly (7)
  • Friendly service (7)
  • Ice Cream (6)
  • Gay-owned (6)
  • Southern / Cajun (6)
  • Great for a date (5)
  • BIPOC-owned (5)
  • Wine Bar (5)
  • Good for brunch (5)
  • Trendy (5)
  • Yum (5)
  • Thai (4)
  • 20-somethings (4)
  • Diner (4)
  • 30-somethings (4)
  • British (4)
  • Scandanavian Restaurant (3)
  • Vegan (3)
  • Foodie heaven (3)
  • Mostly Men (3)
  • Unique (3)
  • Cocktail Bar REstaurant (3)
  • Soul Food (3)
  • Fast Food (3)
  • Middle Eastern (3)
  • Chinese (3)
  • Creative cuisine (3)
  • Awesome wine menu (2)
  • Fish (2)
  • Good for groups (2)
  • Markets (2)
  • Pub/Tavern (2)
  • Steakhouse (2)
  • Dive Bars (2)
  • Upscale/posh (2)
  • Get dessert! (2)
  • Karaoke (1)
  • Great location (1)
  • Tourist Attraction (1)
  • Theater (1)
  • bar food (1)
  • Strong drinks (1)
  • Ethopian (1)
  • Gifts (1)
  • Vietnamese (1)
  • Piano Bar (1)
  • California (1)
  • Spectacle (1)
  • Quirky/funky (1)
  • Drag Shows (1)
  • Cool stuff (1)
  • plants (1)
  • After-hours (1)
  • Cultural Interest (1)
  • Food Market (1)
  • Cocktail Bar (1)
  • Indian (1)
  • Friendly (1)
  • Live Music (1)
  • Neighborhood Bar (1)
  • Cabaret (1)
  • Architecture (1)
  • Mostly Women (1)
More Tags

Neighborhood

  • West Village (26)
  • Hell's Kitchen (25)
  • Chelsea (24)
  • Brooklyn (17)
  • Times Square (14)
  • East Village (13)
  • Upper West Side (13)
  • Soho (10)
  • Lower East Side (7)
  • Harlem (6)
  • Upper East Side (6)
  • Midtown (5)
  • Flatiron District (5)
  • Washington Heights (3)
  • Meatpacking (3)
  • East Side (2)
  • Tribeca (2)
  • Queens (1)
  • Union Square (1)
More neighborhoods
Suggest a Restaurant

Footer

Featured

  • Gay Atlanta
  • Gay Boston
  • Gay Chicago
  • Gay Dallas
  • Gay Fort Lauderdale
  • Gay Las Vegas
  • Gay London

  • Gay LA
  • Gay Montreal
  • Gay Nashville
  • Gay New York
  • Gay Palm Springs
  • Gay San Francisco
  • Gay Sydney

More

  • Destinations
  • Travel Blog
  • Save Queer Spaces
  • Pride Calendar

Connect

  • Advertise with us
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Privacy Notice for California Residents
  • Sitemap

Subscribe to our newsletter

The latest in events, travel destinations, and your favorite places in your inbox weekly.

A proud member of
IGLTA
Facebook Instagram Twitter

Q.Digital   ©2023 GayCities
Proudly LGBTQ+ Owned and Operated 🏳️‍🌈 🏳️‍⚧️

GayCities Gay City Guides

You need to be logged in to go any further.

Continue with Facebook Log In with Foursquare
or
Sign up with email