Lenny's Pizzeria
Lenny's has been serving pies since the Disco days and has made a mark in an unforgiving town. Crispy thin-crust, stringy mozzarella, and that classic New York pizzeria vibe puts this pizza joint on top.
- 20+
- 30+
- family-friendly
- mixed gay/straight
- $$
- American
- cafe
- Italian
- pizza
- sandwiches
- casual
- street food
Your support makes our travel guides possible
We believe that LGBTQ+ people deserve safe vacations that allow them to be their authentic selves. That's why our City Guides aren't locked behind a paywall. Can you contribute today?
Cancel anytime · Proudly LGBTQ+ owned and operated
Reviews
Add a review
garlic knots
THEY NEVER HAVE THEM! Pizza is ok, not phenom. Better off with Dominos IMO.
First to Review
Late Night and Priced Right!
We arrived at 11:30 pm on a Friday Night, early by Manhattan time, but late for Brooklyn. Landing in our friends loft around the corner, and starving from a delayed flight, we walked to Lenny's Pizza. It is the the "pizza place" according to the locals, and one of many throughout the city. The streets were very comfortable for us, two not to intimidating guys, holding hands we walked down to and ordered our Pizza from the primarily Spanish speaking staff. They had multiple varieties of Pizza on display by the slice ( 2 bucks each) and could make us a Full Pie if we wanted to wait. Delivery ends at 11pm. Google shows the hours to close at 11pm, but that is the end of delivery pizza. They are open later for walk up "as long as they have customers." We chose from the 6 or 7 different flavors; they were warmed promptly and the steaming box of pizza was in our hands in under five minutes. 8 slices, 2 16 oz diet cokes for under 20 dollars at midnight in Brooklyn. How can that be bad! The flavor was actually really good. the sign says they make their own sauce and the dough is made daily. Who knew? I'd recommend it!
