Gay New York City
Bars & Clubs
Restaurants
Bathhouses
Hotels
Shops
Arts
Gyms
Beaches
History
Articles
Events

John's of Times Square

(18 Ratings)
Holy Pizza

Incredibly thin crust, brick oven pizza served by the hottest waiters in midtown. The bar is a local hangout with sexy bartenders pouring snazzy cocktails, carafes of Chianti, and pitchers of Brooklyn Lager for the mass of visitors. Celebs are frequently spotted at John's, and the space is often rented out for high-profile events. It used to be a church, so you better believe it's holy pizza.



Your support makes our travel guides possible

We believe that LGBTQ+ people deserve safe vacations that allow them to be their authentic selves. That's why our City Guides aren't locked behind a paywall. Can you contribute today?

Cancel anytime · Proudly LGBTQ+ owned and operated

Reviews

Futbol56
Futbol56
Over a year ago

Pizza Pizza

Great pizza, do some people watching (mostly tourists), and it is a good meal before a show.


isaac82
isaac82
Over a year ago

Holy cocktails (and pizza)

John's is a good spot to carb up. Drinks at the bar is always fun, it's such a gorgeous space. The bartenders are super nice, it's better to eat there instead of a table. Remember, this is a pizza place...order accordingly.


Rivington101
Rivington101
Over a year ago

from heaven

this is the biggest guilty pleasure for me. I can't get enough. Their Bianca pie is my favorite. If you sit at the bar you can people watch and talk to the nice bartenders. If you sit inside you get a room with a total view, and lots of eye candy. It's win win.


xristod
xristod first review First to Review
Over a year ago

Best pizza

Johns has the best pizza in NYC. They cook their pizza in coal fired brick ovens and nothing beats the taste. Make sure you go on Saturdays after the theater rush and have the cute bartender who works on saturdays make you his famous margaritas!!


Other Restaurants in Times Square

Shake Shack

Shake it on over!
Times Square

Sardi's

Time's Square institution
Times Square

Carmine's Italian Restaurant

Family style!
Times Square

Orso

Quaint Italian on Restaurant Row
Times Square

Joe Allen

Dinner and drinks with the theater crowd
Times Square

Bond 45

Steak and Seafood in an infamous location
Times Square

Virgil's Real BBQ - Times Square

Best midtown BBQ
Times Square

Cafe Un Deux Trois

Get your after theater fix in France
Times Square

Gay Bars in New York City

Bar Centrale

Celebrity chic to the max
Hell's Kitchen

Don't Tell Mama

Cabaret multiplex
Hell's Kitchen

The Dickens

Delicious cocktails & food
Hell's Kitchen

9th Avenue Saloon

Packed theater district dive
Hell's Kitchen

Ritz Bar and Lounge

Get ready for some close quarters dancing
Hell's Kitchen

Balcon Salon

Energetic atmosphere and amazing events
Hell's Kitchen

The Skylark

Cocktails with a view
Midtown

VERS

New and shiny gay paradise
Hell's Kitchen

Gay New York City
Bars & Clubs
Restaurants
Bathhouses
Hotels
Shops
Arts
Gyms
Beaches
History
Articles
Events