NY Pizza Suprema

No ratings yet
Cozy slice house

If you’re in need of a quick bite, you won’t have to look hard for a slice shop in NYC. Though you’ll find one of our favorite slices in town at the bustling intersection of 8th Avenue and W 31st Street at NY Pizza Suprema. 

Say a blessing to the photo of trans goddess Colin Atrophy, author of Slice Harvester: A Memoir in Pizza, hanging on the wall in the cramped entryway before rushing out the door back into the street with a box filled with slices and squares.

 



Your support makes our travel guides possible

We believe that LGBTQ+ people deserve safe vacations that allow them to be their authentic selves. That's why our City Guides aren't locked behind a paywall. Can you contribute today?

Cancel anytime · Proudly LGBTQ+ owned and operated

Reviews

No reviews yet, be the first to

Mentioned In

NewFest: How to make the most of this cinematic celebration in the heart of NYC

gay city recs

NewFest: How to make the most of this cinematic celebration in the heart of NYC

Similar Restaurants in New York City

Paul's Da Burger Joint

Family owned and operated
East Village

Knickerbocker Bar & Grill

Jazz and T-Bone Steak
West Village

Corner Bistro

A late-night treasure serving up juicy burgers
West Village

Oscar Wilde

As flamboyant as Oscar himself
Chelsea

Lips

26 years of drag heaven
East Side

Peachy Keen

Wildly and wonderfully retro
Midtown

5 Napkin Burger

Wipe that mouth, you're drooling
Hell's Kitchen

Junior's Restaurant and Bakery

TASTY!!!
Times Square

Gay Bars in Chelsea

Gym Sportsbar

A genuine sports bar in the heart of Chelsea
Chelsea

Boxers NYC

Chelsea sports bar
Chelsea

REBAR Chelsea

Sexy Chelsea hangout
Chelsea

Gotham Comedy Club

From "Last Comic Standing"
Chelsea

Barracuda

Legendary bar and lounge in Chelsea
Chelsea

City Winery New York City

Upscale music venue
Chelsea

Eagle NYC

Classic leather bar
Chelsea