Gay New York City
Bars & Clubs
Restaurants
Bathhouses
Hotels
Shops
Arts
Gyms
Beaches
History
Articles
Events

Schmackary's

(15 Ratings)
Taking cookies to the next level

Schmackary's is finally open! Schmackary's year-round cookie flavors include Oatmeal Scotchie, Peanut Butter Cup White Chocolate Cherry Chunker, Cookies and Cream, and Zachs infamous Red Velvet Cookie. Stop by for a cookie & some milk.



Your support makes our travel guides possible

We believe that LGBTQ+ people deserve safe vacations that allow them to be their authentic selves. That's why our City Guides aren't locked behind a paywall. Can you contribute today?

Cancel anytime · Proudly LGBTQ+ owned and operated

Reviews

Scott
Scott
Over a year ago

wow. worth the calories

The cookies here are truly unbelievable. Maple Bacon is popular and quite amazing but I think lots of the others are even better (yes, I bought a mixed batch). A bit pricey for a cookie, but worth it. Owned by gay former broadway performer and it's open late for an after dinner treat.


JonathanDLovitz
JonathanDLovitz first review First to Review
Over a year ago

The BEST Cookies in NYC

I have never tasted anything like this! Not only are the flavors unique and incredible, the staff, service, and atmosphere are like nothing else in NYC. It's the best of the midwest's charm in the heart of the the Broadway district. They ship nationwide and are guaranteed to make mouths happy anytime you send them to a friend!


Other Restaurants in Hell's Kitchen

El Rancho Burritos

5 star hole in the wall
Hell's Kitchen

5 Napkin Burger

Wipe that mouth, you're drooling
Hell's Kitchen

Nizza

Picture perfect Italian food
Hell's Kitchen

Marseille

A classic French café
Hell's Kitchen

Juice Generation

Get your juice on
Hell's Kitchen

La Pulpería 44th HK

Latin fusion hotspot
Hell's Kitchen

Etcetera Etcetera

Perfect post-theater spot
Hell's Kitchen

Westway Diner

Open 24/7
Hell's Kitchen

Gay Bars in Hell's Kitchen

9th Avenue Saloon

Packed theater district dive
Hell's Kitchen

Ritz Bar and Lounge

Get ready for some close quarters dancing
Hell's Kitchen

Don't Tell Mama

Cabaret multiplex
Hell's Kitchen

Balcon Salon

Energetic atmosphere and amazing events
Hell's Kitchen

Bar Centrale

Celebrity chic to the max
Hell's Kitchen

The Dickens

Delicious cocktails & food
Hell's Kitchen

VERS

New and shiny gay paradise
Hell's Kitchen

Hardware

Hell's Kitchen is sizzling
Hell's Kitchen

Gay New York City
Bars & Clubs
Restaurants
Bathhouses
Hotels
Shops
Arts
Gyms
Beaches
History
Articles
Events